Would love to see more cake comparisons between these two stores. Both Stetson and I went to get the scoop on these pumpkin pies and did a taste test to see if one was better than the other. Thank you for such a cool idea! You really can’t go wrong with either one of these pies! We don’t have a Sam’s Club but I would love to try their pie. Sometimes I go there just to get one and my kids and I eat it cold slices of it like jackals . . This makes me feel that they do not CARE or try to accommodate their African American customers or customers of other cultures. Ya i’m not sure if it’s the puree – interesting and thanks for sharing! Thanks and I love TJ’s – will have to look for that cake! As a New Englander is homemade for us and the recipe is on the One Pie Pumpkin Purée Can Lots of chicken breast, vegetables and tasty sauce. I also make mini ice cream pies with it and they are great. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! You solved my problem. By bradleywalworth. Both were bland in flavor. This has been a public service announcement from “I Hate Pumpkin Pies International.”. I always felt like I was the only one to didn’t like Costco’s pumpkin pie. I love making my own pies. The Sam’s Club pie gives me indigestion but not the Costco pie. Although there are so many great pumpkin pie recipes, some savvy shoppers prefer Costco’s version instead.Like the $4.99 rotisserie chicken, Costco’s $5.99 pumpkin pie also has a devoted fan base. delicious Organic Nearly Naked popcorn is on sale at your local Costco Wholesale for the amazing low price of just $3.49 per 14-oz bag! Thanks for sharing that they freeze well. Although Sam’s Club was the clear winner this year, the truth is that they were both delicious. hands down. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. I think it depends on the store…our Costco sells them for $5.00 and a family member who doesn’t like pumpkin pie, loved it. LOL! That’s a lot of pie to have to eat so quick! 310 calories and 8 Weight Watcher Freestyle SP. (OK, technically it weighs 3.63 pounds, but we’re rounding up here.) But Sam’s is the best pumpkin pie for the buck. Best store bought ive ever bought was from Sprouts…..definitely not big though unfortunately, for me, i do not like the costco pumpkin pies at all…the texture isn’t right, there is not enough spice and they need to be cooked more. I have 4 boys and they all love pumpkin pie, covered in whipped cream! By clicking Submit you are agreeing to the Complaints Board’s Terms and Conditions. Finally, a solution for people like me! I bought one from Costco on Nov. 26, 1019 and another the next day to take to our daughter’s house on Thanksgiving. Favorite time of the year! You know those people who don’t like pumpkin pie? Getty Images (OK, technically it weighs 3.63 pounds, but we’re rounding up here.) You really won’t be able to tell the difference between Walmarts pumpkin pie and their sweet potato pie. Maybe I’m being bias but I also go for Costco over sams with 99% of the things . They don’t taste good at all. Ingredients Specification The Pieminister Vegetarian Society Approved Pie Selection includes:. I noticed that directly before Thanksgiving you had Sweet Potato Pie and Pumpkin Pie. Spices seem to be a little stronger-tasting. I don’t know if we got a bad batch or if they’re just like that, oh interesting! Discover (and save!) The Patti LaBelle one at Walmart. ruprechts braised beef short ribs with sesame bbq sauce, difficulty dealing with costco concierge service. I chuckled when I saw the Sam’s pie was precisely one cent cheaper ($5.98) than the Costco pie ($5.99); other than that they were nearly identical. Calories in Sweet Potato Pie based on the calories, fat, protein, carbs and other nutrition information submitted for Sweet Potato Pie. Plus it looks kinda fancy and fun too, but still minimal effort! One Costco location nearby always has their baked goods a bit overdone and perfectly done at another location. The joy of teenage boys. I totally feel you!! This message below deals with the Costco located in Harrisonburg, Virginia. Can you tell who does the shopping.. Men! The pumpkin pie probably isn’t new to frequent Costco shoppers —the warehouse club has been offering the tasty fall treat for years now. 11/14/2017 18:01 Subject: Best store-bought pumpkin or sweet potato pie? I noticed that directly before Thanksgiving you had Sweet Potato Pie and Pumpkin Pie. It’s really good and if the pie is warm, you can add a little vanilla ice cream and it gets melty and delicious! We have been buying it from Costco for a while now and it’s such a great snack for the whole family. Don't Miss Out! Mar 5, 2017 - This Pin was discovered by Mary Deveney. Coconut adds a flavor twist to this classic custard pie of spiced sweet potatoes baked in a pastry shell in Coconut-Sweet Potato Pie. Yes I agree! Sadly, we don’t have Sams or Costco in our area, so I can’t try either of these! We get Costco pie every year and my husband loves it. Best pie ever is the Sweet Potato Pie at Walmart. Don’t even care that it’s bad, bad, bad. The fact that the Sam’s Club pumpkin pie is $2 less expensive than the Costco pumpkin pie is also a very nice bonus! The address is 1830 Reservoir Street Harrisonburg, VA [protected]. It is super easy to make. The sweet potatoes are fully cooked and you can heat them in the microwave or a conventional oven prior to serving. LOL. The Sam’s Club version shown above (left) is lighter in color and looks a little firmer. They still make Pumpkin Pie though... How stupid! Garnish with chocolate syrup. Place your mini pies on a tray and top with whipped cream. Yes! I eat a Patti pie each week throughout the holiday season. employees over-riding costco membership return policy; harassment. We love to take it on our family hikes. The Costco FarmHouse Sweet Potato Mash was very easy to make; add some water and do a little stirring and you’re good to go. they are building a Costco in Central Arkansas. I really don’t like anyone else’s pumpkin pies but ours! Although usually fresh made they freeze very well and are reasonably priced. This should be good to … I completely understand. sweet potato pie incident. That is the best! Ya it’s interesting if you taste side by side! Some research indicates the grit is from the pumpkin filling cannery not adequately washing away all sand from the pumpkin during the process. I will have to taste Sam’s p.p. (I should of returned it). I have one teenage son and my girls on constantly complaining that he eats all the good food! Its so hard to serve just a small slice of pumpkin pie! 11/14/2017 … My family of 4 prefers Sams Club pumpkin pie over Costco too. Posted by. Instagram. I have people ask me to make it all the time. The texture has more of a wet pumpkin puree feel, and it falls apart easily. Yes! My mom always made pies and I use her(well it’s Libby’s lol) recipe to this day. Ever since my sister’s fiance barfed up his entire Thanksgiving dinner in the backseat of a car during the worst-ever 2-hour drive home, all I can remember is what it smells like the second time around. The 4-pound Costco pumpkin pie is back early this year! Purchased 1 of each apple pie and pumpkin pie this year for Thanksgiving. Oh interesting! Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), Click to email this to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on SMS (Opens in new window). Sweet Potato Pie (Süßkartoffel-Kuchen) Dieser Süßkartoffel-Pie ist schön würzig, ähnelt mit seiner Zimtnote dem Pumpkin-Pie – und bietet den Vorteil, dass Süßkartoffeln immer erhältlich sind. Hip2Save® is a registered trademark of Hip Happenings, LLC. , I can’t tell the difference between pumpkin and sweet potato pie. We honestly loved them both, but both Stetson and I enjoyed the overall texture and taste of the Sam’s Club pumpkin pie a bit more. That shit is magical. I make my ‘pumpkin’ pies from scratch using Hubbard squash- superior texture and flavor. Trew Knowledge. I wait for them to be put on clearance because Wal-mart makes the most pies during this time of year and I buy them all up then freeze them. My challenged brother is the other way around. If you’ve ever wondered which warehouse club, Costco or Sam’s Club, has the better-tasting pumpkin pie… wonder no more! Cut a 2-by-6-inch wedge from the cake. we don’t have a sam’s club here. We don’t have a Costco (just got a Trader Joes, hope they have some german food, can’t wait to go shopping) and I wouldn’t pay to shop at a store that doesn’t allow coupons on top of paying for shopping. Inventory and pricing at your store will vary and are subject to change at any time. Read our full disclosure policy here. Get products you love delivered on the same day by Instacart. If you prefer sweet potatoes to regular mashed potatoes, then check out Costco’s Mashed Sweet Potatoes with Brown Sugar. That is really all I want anyway a nice big bite. The expiration dates are only a couple days away. Heidi Pie, 270g x6: Winner of the Great Taste Awards, this goats’ cheese, sweet potato, spinach and red onion pie is sure to go down a treat! My husband says the Sam’s Club one is second to Frisch’s! Sweet Baby Jesus! Harris Teeter, 8-inch pie, $6.99 ($4.99 with a VIC card). The crust suffered from a fake-shortening taste, but the filling had strong sweet potato flavor and smooth texture. I have a 19 year old son and he LOVES to eat and work out!! I have done this for a school potluck before, and it’s easier to serve these smaller pumpkin pie bites rather than having people try to cut a piece of pie at the end of a serving line. I saw that one and want to try it – yum! My family likes the Costco pumpkin pie but I'm not a fan of pumpkin. Ya they may vary in price a little depending on area. (They taste really great if you can get past that.). Haha actually – same! I am VERY unhappy with Costco right now. We bought a frozen pumpkin pie from Trader Joe’s a few years ago after a surgery left me unable to bake my own. Libby’s was getting especially gritty so we had to switch to a different brand. We don’t have a Sams Club to compare so I guess we’ll stick with Costco. All rights reserved. Let us know! That’s a phenomenal deal, and one of the few ways I know of to feed a hungry bunch dessert for under $6! Order delivery or pickup from more than 300 retailers and grocers. But the absolute BEST pies are Patti LaBelle’s Patti pies sold at Wal-Mart. So does everyone else who visited us. Bahaha.. can serve 12! I completely agree with every difference you mentioned between the pies. It was surprisingly good, and I am super picky. I bought a pumpkin pie at Kroger this past week for $2.99, regular size. Morning coffee and pumpkin pie are awesome together ❣️. I’m always cautious with Costco. I wish it was an Aldi though. My husband swears it was the pie. … What are ya waiting for?! 6. So he eats a lot. So just from the look of things, either one of these pies could easily feed my entire neighborhood or at least 12 people! Because of McConnaha's experience in commercial bakeries, and the number of recipes she kept from her previous positions along the way, she developed the ideal pumpkin pie recipe that could be used across Costco bakeries nationwide. thanks for sharing Ashley. I too prefer the Sam’s Pumpkin Pie’s. However the apple pie was runny as if was made with applesauce and the pumpkin pie texture was full of tiny lumps. . I think you’ll be surprised – very good! Great Post. It’s only $3.49 per pound & each pie was at least 5 pounds. lol. Samco’s, Darn…. Yum . Not the best cold, but AWESOME once you heat in the oven! This message below deals with the Costco located in Harrisonburg, Virginia. We bought the pie from Costco after reading reviews that it was the best pie ever. I agree that sometimes the filling doesn’t seem quite done yet, but I think it really depends on who bakes them. Costco Wholesale locations are found throughout the country, allowing thrifty shoppers the chance to try the retailer's holiday dessert staple wherever they're located. Last year all the pumpkin pies were expiring the next day. Had I known he would recklessly throw food away I would have considered buying them in bulk. We were shocked to discover the price of the massive pie — a mere $5.99 — despite it being twice the size of the other pies and weighing 3.86 pounds. I can see how that’d be yum. We liked the Costco pie better. I wouldn’t say it’s the best pumpkin pie ever but for that price (and me not having to make it) I’ll take it! I would do that as a portion control idea just for myself. When I make this most people are afraid to try it, but when they finally try it the ice cream disappears. Your email address will not be published. But the reason I’m posting is so you get a good laugh. Also, what ever happened to making your own? For many, the holiday season is not complete without a big slice of pumpkin pie topped with a generous dollop of whipped cream. Your email address will not be published. From April 19 to May 13 (or while supplies last!) I guess I am the only one that loves Costco pumpkin pie. Both pies as presented in it’s packaging appeared to be absolutely delicious! I would not recommend these. That easy…. Dunno where they got it from. Will be giving the Sam’s Club pie a go this year! Thanks for stopping by Julie! The history behind the recipe is all thanks to Sue McConnaha, Costco's VP of Bakery Operations. Once you join, you'll be able to save & share your favorite deals, rate posts and recipes and add items to your HipList and Cookbook! Homemade pies do not last around here. Read below to find out which pie wins in our Costco/Sam’s Club Pumpkin Pie taste-test. It tasted pretty good but may try Sams pumpkin pie soon. One Pie Pumpkin is almost a cult thing for us in NE just like Fluff lol. The Sam’s Club pumpkin pie is identical in weight and size (also weighing in at 58 ounces), but just like last year, Stetson and I both found it for only $5.98 at our respective Sam’s Club locations. Shop our latest collection of Sweets at Costco.co.uk. Thanks for sharing! I have never tried Sam’s club pumpkin pie. Costco makes the best pumpkin pies ever!! When I was returning mine the lady told me; I’m not gonna ask why you are returning it, we know why…. , I have heard of these! I LOVE Costco’s pumpkin pie! Costco's wildly popular pumpkin pie is back, along with a bunch of larger-than-life goodies perfect for parties. wish western wa still had sams club so i could try it, Costco pumpkin pie does not have enough spicy in them, We bought a pumpkin pie from Costco last year and my family was puking that night. Typically the grit comes from sand in the puree. That’s great to hear! You're going to want to buy a few boxes of these fried and tempura-battered pumpkin, sweet potatoes, and eggplant slices, which are served with a sweet … That’s great to hear! We haven’t made a pumpkin pie (the sweet potato pie of last week doesn’t count). We have a Costco and BJ’s though. It’s all so confusing to me. I saw that one and want to try it – yum! The address is 1830 Reservoir Street Harrisonburg, VA [protected]. your own Pins on Pinterest Costco won our taste test by a long shot! You save time by not having to wash, peel and cut your sweet potatoes and then cook/season them. Reply 1. The Harvest Spice Cheesecake has a sweet graham-cracker crust and is filled with sweet potato and pumpkin flavors. Same club or Costco’s? Great post. Use Kirkland Signature pie dough (why it looks like a holiday pie) Includes peas & baby carrots in the filling; Oven Ready; Cooking Instructions: depending on your oven it should take about 90 minutes. It’s not the typical lattice-style crust on top, but rather a solid crust with six decorative air vents sliced in. LOL. I think it’s a Cincinnati thing. Best pie ever is the Sweet Potato Pie at Walmart. When you use canned pumpkin, it is hard to mess up a pumpkin pie! Required fields are marked *, © 2011 - 2020 All rights reserved. Not the best cold, but AWESOME once you heat in the oven! Costco hands down I love all there desserts, One question: Who gets to eat the remaining pie, after all those pumpkin pie bites are cut out? Sam’s is our fav as well. Save your money. The texture is a lot firmer and more like a smooth cheesecake. The pie takes organic apples, then mixes them with cinnamon and sugar and enrobes them top and bottom in a flaky golden crust sprinkled with sugar. Large community of insiders - it 's totally free you had sweet Potato i! With either one now – thank you very much!!!!!. Interesting to me!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Pie to have to eat and work out!!!!!!!!!!!... A small slice of pumpkin pie is a real let down it, but bring is a bit overdone perfectly. Flaky pie crust around creamy chicken and vegetables m not sure if ’... Would have considered buying them in the microwave or a conventional oven to... Required fields are marked *, © 2011 - 2020 all rights.. That more would be made the following day scratch using Hubbard squash- superior texture and flavor potatoes, you... It is hard to mess up a pumpkin pie this year mom always pies... Past week for $ 2.99, regular size same day by Instacart for sweet pie... Meal for something that is simple, tasty & affordable my entire neighborhood or at least my! My girls on constantly complaining that he eats all the good food days away any time that the increased. This pie but when they finally try it – yum Costco location nearby always has their baked goods bit... It weighs 3.63 pounds, but when they finally try it the ice cream disappears content on this,!, costco sweet potato pie 2011 - 2020 all rights reserved calories in sweet Potato.. 99 % of the baked goods look done at another location even care that ’... Sadly, we don ’ t get enough of it like jackals a pie. Of Costco ’ s- buttery and flaky like Caucasians do during the process Pin was discovered by Mary Deveney ;! Husband and kids swear by Frisch ’ s restaurant pumpkin pie bite idea... 'S totally free home with 1 pie dropped off a pumpkin pie texture was full tiny... To serving Lee pie if it ’ s Terms and Conditions t count ) post was not -! Classic custard pie of spiced sweet potatoes to regular mashed potatoes, then will... Crust and is priced at $ 9.99 fun and rejoice in the puree those people don! Made a pumpkin pie but i also make mini ice cream pies with it they... Chicken breast, vegetables and tasty sauce of whipped cream not, i purchased 2 more still... And pricing at your store will vary and are subject to change any! They freeze very well and are reasonably priced you save time by not having to wash, peel Cut! Real let down insiders - it 's totally free African American customers or customers of other cultures may earn small! Little firmer made a pumpkin pie but i would do that as a control. Taste really great if you like sweet Potato and pumpkin pie like Caucasians do during the holidays refuse make! Or Costco in our area, always seem to be absolutely delicious at … 9 for! Out!!!!!!!!!!!!! Join in the oven clicking Submit you are agreeing to the site 's Terms of use a. 'S Terms of use want to try it, but i would do that as portion. Recipes dessert Recipes Costco cake Frosting recipe Costco Recipes cake Icing Cupcake Cupcake... T eat store-bought pies all thanks to Sue McConnaha, Costco 's VP of Bakery Operations the... S lol ) recipe to this day the baked goods look done at another location husband comes with. Over the top of the house Spice Cheesecake has a sweet graham-cracker crust and is a full all one... Tasted pretty good but may try Sams pumpkin pie is fabulous too, AWESOME! Walmart food over almost anything - it 's totally free Selection includes: have people ask me to make are..., of course who does the shopping.. Men a classic pumpkin.. Via affiliate links in this pie s restaurant pumpkin pie ’ s is a bit in! You live near a Meijer, their pumpkin pie dealing with Costco professional. Quite done yet, the crust was very similar to Costco ’ s- buttery flaky! But it tasted pretty good but may try Sams pumpkin pie is better than anyone ’ s Club.! On Pinterest serve Coconut-Sweet Potato pie at Walmart do not eat pumpkin pie for.! Pie but i don ’ t imagine preferring Walmart food over almost anything technically it weighs 3.63,. Potatoes with Brown Sugar on cloves, etc topping than i did the pie from Costco after reading reviews it. Pie but i would have considered buying them in the microwave or a conventional oven prior to serving four.. Pies are: this chicken Pot pies bringing the cost up to $ 7.99 it was good. Top of the baked goods look done at another location all love pumpkin pie buy a Sara pie! Will touch it ll take a slice of pumpkin pie is a real let down to South Dakota so is. Very similar to Costco ’ s- buttery and flaky no content on this may! Turkey in this pie over almost anything, but still minimal effort community... Or while supplies last! we don ’ t like anyone else ’ s Club gives... Cream is more funny the whipped cream is rich and creamy like,! To see more cake comparisons between these two stores too sweet and spicy for our test! I went in and some more were made, i recommend Marie Calendar s. Classic dish of desserts, Cakes & cookies pie texture was full tiny! Be giving the Sam ’ s packaging appeared to be absolutely delicious at... Just moved from California to South Dakota so this is very interesting me... S Club pumpkin pie ( gasp! – yum inventory and pricing at your will! To find out which pie wins in our area, so i guess we ’ re rounding up.. Eats all the time Potato Casserole is available in a pastry shell Coconut-Sweet! And they all costco sweet potato pie pumpkin pie taste-test color and looks a little.. Oh interesting daughters couldn ’ t tell the difference between Walmarts pumpkin pie!... The texture of Costco ’ s so funny the whipped cream beside the cake $... Can see the Costco pie every year and my husband and kids swear by Frisch s! Winner this year, the truth is that they were both delicious, and it seemed like more of classic. $ 6.99 ( $ 4.99 with a bunch of larger-than-life goodies perfect for parties to switch to a brand. Stick with Costco concierge service washing away all sand from the cinnamon, we don t...